A Swedish study tracking 2 million women has ignited a firestorm of misinformation about birth control.
Story Snapshot
- Swedish researchers found hormonal contraceptives increase breast cancer risk by 24%, but that translates to only 13 extra cases per 100,000 women annually
- Social media amplified and distorted the findings, with some claiming birth control is as dangerous as smoking
- Medical experts emphasize the absolute risk remains extremely low and hormonal contraception is still safe for most women
- The controversy highlights how complex scientific data gets weaponized in our misinformation-prone digital age
The Numbers Behind the Headlines
The Swedish study, published in JAMA Oncology, followed over 2 million women under age 50 for more than a decade. Researchers found that women using hormonal contraceptives had a 24% higher rate of breast cancer compared to non-users. This sounds alarming until you understand what it actually means in real terms.
The absolute risk increase translates to approximately 13 additional breast cancer cases per 100,000 women per year. To put this in perspective, you’re more likely to be struck by lightning than develop breast cancer from taking the pill. Yet within hours of publication, social media transformed these nuanced findings into panic-inducing headlines.
Watch:
How Science Gets Twisted in the Digital Echo Chamber
The study’s authors, Åsa Johansson and Fatemeh Hadizadeh from Uppsala University, carefully contextualized their findings. They emphasized the modest, short-term nature of the risk increase and stressed the importance of individualized patient counseling. Their measured approach, however, couldn’t compete with viral misinformation.
Social media influencers cherry-picked statistics, removed context, and made wild comparisons. Some posts falsely equated birth control’s cancer risk with smoking, despite smoking increasing lung cancer risk by 1,500-3,000%. Others ignored that the study included non-invasive lesions that may never become life-threatening cancers, potentially inflating the apparent risk.
Breast Cancer and Birth Control: A Huge New Study Shows How Science Can Be Distorted https://t.co/xLGzieet5Y via @KFF
"TikTok is flooded with factually incomplete warnings that contraceptives cause cancer and are as dangerous as smoking."
— Timothy Caulfield (@CaulfieldTim) November 18, 2025
What Medical Experts Actually Say
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists maintains that hormonal contraception remains appropriate for most women. The National Cancer Institute notes that the risk from hormonal contraceptives is significantly lower than other established breast cancer risk factors like age, family history, or alcohol consumption.
Dr. Mary Rosser from Columbia University and other experts emphasize that women shouldn’t change their contraceptive choices based solely on this study. Meanwhile, hormonal contraceptives provide substantial benefits including reduced risks of ovarian and endometrial cancers.
The Real Danger: Fear-Based Decision Making
The most concerning outcome isn’t the modest cancer risk the study identified—it’s the potential for women to make poor health decisions based on distorted information. Unintended pregnancies carry far greater health risks than the marginal breast cancer increase from hormonal contraceptives.
Pregnancy itself temporarily increases breast cancer risk more than birth control pills do. Additionally, access to reliable contraception enables women to plan their families, pursue education and careers, and maintain economic stability. These broader health and social benefits vastly outweigh the small cancer risk increase.
Sources:
KFF Health News – Breast Cancer and Birth Control: A Huge New Study Shows How Science Can Be Distorted
UT Southwestern Medical Center – Birth Control and Breast Cancer
Uppsala University – Breast Cancer Risk Varies Between Different Hormonal Contraceptives
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists – Hormonal Contraception and Risk of Breast Cancer
CBS News – Huge New Study on Breast Cancer and Birth Control Shows How Science Can Be Distorted
PMC – Research Article on Hormonal Contraceptives and Breast Cancer
MD Anderson Cancer Center – The Pill and Cancer: Is There a Link?
Times of India – Pill Taken by Millions of Women Linked to Breast Cancer Risk
